Negative

Negative is a landscape project on the aftermath of the political unrest in Hong Kong. It aims to expose personal and collective traumatic memory existing on the veneer of the Hong Kong cityscape, unveil the national consciousness of Hongkongers after facing a disastrous revolt and propose a new visual strategy to refamiliarize the violent event by photographing the traces remaining on public space.

After anti extradition law amendment protests in 2019, Hong Kong seems to be back to normal. However, the tiny traces on the city's corner have wrought an indelible trauma on all; Hong Kong has been taken away, and many are psychologically shaken and changed. So as, the Hong Kong cityscape, covered as it was by protest slogans and the remnants of Molotov cocktails, conveyed the memory of resistance and the battle against political violence. It signifies the determination of Hongkongers to fight against autocracy. The battles that took place on the streets and in different landmarks surrounding the business district of Hong Kong carry the memory of violent events and induce cultural trauma which individuals in the community lose their identity and hope.

This project considers inverted imagery as a metaphor to depict cultural feelings, mourn for the loss and expose the latency of my own PTSD experience. The images were taken in the places that carry my emotional attachment to the unrest days after, months after and years after the protests. Some emotions are about the fear induced by National Security Law, and some are about the loss of hope. Those feelings are not spontaneously come into my life. Instead, they are slowly triggered by my daily encounters afterward. I argue that the images in this project have a structural resemblance to trauma. My sleeps are occupied by surreal nightmares. The photographs of the traces are the representation of my consciousness and memory of the anti-ELAB protests. And Many were forced to exile.

© Jimmy Lee - Image from the Negative photography project
i

A Mass Transit Railway station exit was burned by Molotov cocktail during the anti-extradition bill conflict. Most traces from the political unrest were cleaned up or removed by the government. However there are few left in the city. The fence that police built to prevent protesters throwing things accidentally preserve the burning marks.

© Jimmy Lee - A street corner with slogans and posters has been cleaned up.
i

A street corner with slogans and posters has been cleaned up.

© Jimmy Lee - The traces of a Molotov cocktail in this image were made during the anti-ELAB conflict.
i

The traces of a Molotov cocktail in this image were made during the anti-ELAB conflict.

© Jimmy Lee - Grey Paint covered up the traces of a slogan under the bridge.
i

Grey Paint covered up the traces of a slogan under the bridge.

© Jimmy Lee - Image from the Negative photography project
i

During the protest, protesters used spray to do graffiti all around the route of the march. The plain white background accidentally became the canvas of the protest art. After awhile the cleaner worked for the tram company used detergent to clean it up. However the cleaners were not able to fully erase the graffiti. The remain is an analogy to the fight between memory and forgotten.

© Jimmy Lee - Image from the Negative photography project
i

During the protest, protesters used spray to do graffiti all around the route of the march. The plain white background accidentally became the canvas of the protest art. After awhile the cleaner worked for the tram company used detergent to clean it up. However the cleaners were not able to fully erase the graffiti. The remain is an analogy to the fight between memory and forgotten.

© Jimmy Lee - Image from the Negative photography project
i

During the protest, protesters used spray to do graffiti all around the route of the march. The plain white background accidentally became the canvas of the protest art. After awhile the cleaner worked for the tram company used detergent to clean it up. However the cleaners were not able to fully erase the graffiti. The remain is an analogy to the fight between memory and forgotten.

© Jimmy Lee - Image from the Negative photography project
i

This set of triptych was taken on the first day of the launch of the Hong Kong National Security Law. The NSL, until now, has prosecuted hundreds of democratic activists and supporters. Although Hong Kong Government claims NSL could help bring stability back to Hong Kong society, many see that as fear.

© Jimmy Lee - Image from the Negative photography project
i

This set of triptych was taken on the first day of the launch of the Hong Kong National Security Law. The NSL, until now, has prosecuted hundreds of democratic activists and supporters. Although Hong Kong Government claims NSL could help bring stability back to Hong Kong society, many see that as fear.

© Jimmy Lee - Image from the Negative photography project
i

This set of triptych was taken on the first day of the launch of the Hong Kong National Security Law. The NSL, until now, has prosecuted hundreds of democratic activists and supporters. Although Hong Kong Government claims NSL could help bring stability back to Hong Kong society, many see that as fear.

© Jimmy Lee - Grey Paint covered up the traces of a slogan under the bridge.
i

Grey Paint covered up the traces of a slogan under the bridge.

© Jimmy Lee - Grey Paint covered up the traces of a slogan under the bridge.
i

Grey Paint covered up the traces of a slogan under the bridge.

© Jimmy Lee - Image from the Negative photography project
i

San Uk Ling Holding Centre is located in a remote area near Hong Kong-China border. During the anti-extradition law amendment protests, authority altered the compound purpose from holding Chinese illegal immigrants, to detain and interrogate protesters, and there are some allegations of abusive interrogation method which caused prisoners seriously injured.

© Jimmy Lee - Image from the Negative photography project
i

The government built many metal fences during and after the protests to avoid protesters throwing stuff from the bridge. Later on, it became a permanent landscape marking the "that-has-been" resistance against the unfair and unjust. It also symbolises the current situation of Hongkongers who were being cornered and living in a prison-like city, losing their freedom.

© Jimmy Lee - Image from the Negative photography project
i

Years after the first photo-shoot of Hung Hom Railway Station, I revisited the location, and found that all the traces have been cleaned off.

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Stay in the loop


We will send you weekly news on contemporary photography. You can change your mind at any time. We will treat your data with respect. For more information please visit our privacy policy. By ticking here, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with them. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.