How was your dream ?

« How was your dream ? » is a documentary photographic project realized during the Hong Kong protests between June and October 2019. This work deals with new forms of demonstration and insurrection in our post-contemporary era dominated by seamless control societies. The title refers to the turn of phrase used by the demonstrators to securely evoke their demonstration experiences.

Even if this theme, which I have been developing for several years, requires me to take part in a certain number of manifestations and social events, my artistic practice tends to get rid of the codes of photojournalism that usually comes along the classic representation of news. My goal is to search and explore a timeless, symbolic aesthetic that apprehends reality through the correspondences and echoes of a multiplicity of singular images.

Five years ago the « umbrella movement » was quickly repressed by state and police violence. In 2019 the democratic uprising that began in May gave itself the means to continue. Faced with a sophisticated arsenal of control (facial recognition, geolocation, carding, eavesdropping, infiltration, water cannons, tear gas, helicopter, sonic weapons, non-lethal rifles), the Hong Kong demonstrators have developed a repertoire of techniques based on principles of invisibility and intraceability (anonymity, lasers of blindness, pocket of faraday, vision by drones, masks of all kinds, encrypted communication etc…), allowing them to mitigate the effects of the repression.

These new devices, which contribute to the transformation of the forms of struggle and resistance, however, push for the gradual erasure of individual singularities. In the future, will societies and sophisticated systems of control, force us to make our human singularities disappear? Will this be done in favor of a new common identity ?

As evokes the novelist and philosopher Alain Damasio in La zone du dehors « The end justifies the means… But who will justify the end ? »

© Thaddé Comar - Blossom Everywhere (Motto used to invite protesters to attempt actions anywhere in the city.)
i

Blossom Everywhere (Motto used to invite protesters to attempt actions anywhere in the city.)

© Thaddé Comar - Image from the How was your dream ? photography project
i

Black Police (The term "Black Police" used by the demonstrators is an allusion to the suspected collusion between the police forces and the triads ( also called "black society"). )

© Thaddé Comar - Peanut Eaters (Name people watching the manifestations are called by the protesters. )
i

Peanut Eaters (Name people watching the manifestations are called by the protesters. )

© Thaddé Comar - Image from the How was your dream ? photography project
i

Freedom Cunts ("Freedom cunts" an insult first used in June by the police against protester and caught on camera. Since then, many Hong Kongers have reclaimed the insult as a badge of honor. )

© Thaddé Comar - It's Raining (Name of this tactic used to hide radical actions. )
i

It's Raining (Name of this tactic used to hide radical actions. )

© Thaddé Comar - The Water Dance 1 (Popular nickname for water cannon. )
i

The Water Dance 1 (Popular nickname for water cannon. )

© Thaddé Comar - The Water Dance 2 (Popular nickname for water cannon. )
i

The Water Dance 2 (Popular nickname for water cannon. )

© Thaddé Comar - Comrade 1 (Protesters are ironically using this communist terme to define each others. )
i

Comrade 1 (Protesters are ironically using this communist terme to define each others. )

© Thaddé Comar - Comrade 2 (Protesters are ironically using this communist terme to define each others. )
i

Comrade 2 (Protesters are ironically using this communist terme to define each others. )

© Thaddé Comar - Comrade 3 (Protesters are ironically using this communist terme to define each others. )
i

Comrade 3 (Protesters are ironically using this communist terme to define each others. )

© Thaddé Comar - Image from the How was your dream ? photography project
i

Smart Eyes (Nickname given to cameras since the Suspicions about the implementation of Chinese facial recognition systems in Hong Kong.)

© Thaddé Comar - Image from the How was your dream ? photography project
i

The Shrine (The Prince Edward station exit B1 became a shrine after police raided groups of demonstrators inside the subway. )

© Thaddé Comar - furtives 1
i

furtives 1

© Thaddé Comar - furtives 2
i

furtives 2

© Thaddé Comar - Run & Hit (Name of the tactic used by police during late night demonstrations. )
i

Run & Hit (Name of the tactic used by police during late night demonstrations. )

© Thaddé Comar - The Wizard (Nickname from DOTA game for drones used by protesters. )
i

The Wizard (Nickname from DOTA game for drones used by protesters. )

© Thaddé Comar - Image from the How was your dream ? photography project
i

Laser Guns (At a police press conference, the protester's lasers were described as "laser guns". Since then, the therme has been used with irony. )

© Thaddé Comar - Fu Fu Fu (“伏伏伏” is the sound of the helicopter operating, also the word 伏 stand for "Ambush". )
i

Fu Fu Fu (“伏伏伏” is the sound of the helicopter operating, also the word 伏 stand for "Ambush". )

© Thaddé Comar - The Dream
i

The Dream

© Thaddé Comar - Teargas City (Nickname of Hong Kong. )
i

Teargas City (Nickname of Hong Kong. )

Latest Projects

  • Like the Waves Appear and Disappear and Appear Again

  • Angle of Draw

  • You Are Everything to Me

  • Close to the ground, far from heaven

  • You Wouldn't Be So Depressed if You Really Believed in God

  • Strawberry blue

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Stay in the loop


We will send you weekly news on contemporary photography. You can change your mind at any time. We will treat your data with respect. For more information please visit our privacy policy. By ticking here, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with them. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.